Conformal prediction can be used to construct prediction sets that cover the true outcome with a desired probability, but can sometimes lead to large prediction sets that are costly in practice. The most useful outcome is a singleton prediction---an unambiguous decision---yet existing efficiency-oriented methods primarily optimize average set size. Motivated by this, we propose a new non-conformity score that is motivated by minimizing the probability of producing non-singleton sets while maintaining coverage. Starting from a non-convex constrained optimization problem as a motivation, we provide a convex-geometric reformulation and associated algorithm for computing the non-conformity score and associated split conformal prediction sets in $O(K)$ time for $K$-class problems. Using this score in split conformal prediction, we introduce Singleton-Optimized Conformal Prediction (SOCOP). We evaluate our method in experiments on image classification and LLM multiple-choice answering, comparing with standard non-conformity scores such as the (negative) label probability estimates and their cumulative distribution function; both of which are motivated by aiming to optimize average length. The results show that SOCOP increases singleton frequency (sometimes by over 20\%) compared to the above scores, with minimal impact on average set size.